Experimental Study on the Influence of Air Side Equalizing Device on the Flow Heat Transfer Characteristics of Cooling Delta Unit

doi:10.12096/j.2096-4528.pgt.22094

Abstract

Abstract:

For the cooling delta unit, the basic heat transfer element of the cold end of the indirect air-cooling system, the wind speed, air temperature, and wall temperature measuring points were arranged laterally along the heat transfer bundle in the cooling columns on both sides of cooling delta with or without air equalizing apparatus. The wall temperature measuring points were further arranged on the left and right side of water outlet cooling columns. The changes of lateral windward wind speed, wind temperature, wall temperature and outlet water temperature of the cooling columns on both sides along the heat transfer bundles were compared and analyzed. And the influence mechanisms of the air equalizing apparatus on the flow and heat transfer characteristics of the cooling delta unit and the outlet water temperature were studied. The results show that, with the air equalizing apparatus, the distribution of lateral windward wind speed and wall temperature of the two sides cooling columns are more uniform along the heat transfer bundle.

Key words: coal-fired power unit, indirect air-cooling system, cooling delta, air side equalizing device, flow heat transfer, water temperature distribution

CLC Number:

TK 124

Tao GUO, Haiyang YU, Haibo FENG, Hanchuan YUAN, Bing TIAN, Yujie YANG, Yuanbin ZHAO, Qian ZHAO. Experimental Study on the Influence of Air Side Equalizing Device on the Flow Heat Transfer Characteristics of Cooling Delta Unit[J]. Power Generation Technology, 2024, 45(1): 79-89.

Figures/Tables 22

Fig. 1 Relative position of each cooling sectors for a dry cooling tower

Fig. 2 Position of 8 and 9 cooling delta units in the third cooling sector

Fig. 3 Air side equalizing device and the original structure cooling delta unit

Fig. 4 Measurement point installation position of the 8 and 9 cooling delta unit

Fig. 5 Installation location of the wall water column temperature measurement point

Tab. 1 Experimental measurement parameters and instruments

测量参数	仪表	测量范围	测量精度
环境风向	WD4510风向传感器	0~360°	±1°
环境风速	WD4510风速传感器	0~10 m/s	±0.02 m/s
环境风温	温度传感器	-40~+80 ℃	±0.05 ℃
迎风风速	管道式风速仪	0~20 m/s	±0.02 m/s
迎风风温	PT100探针式温度传感器	-50~200 ℃	±0.1 ℃
迎风壁温	PT100贴片贴片温度传感器	-50~200 ℃	±0.1 ℃

Fig. 6 Windward wind velocity distribution of the 8 cooling delta unit cooling column

Fig. 7 Windward wind velocity distribution of the 9 cooling delta unit cooling column

Tab. 2 Range of wind velocity in sector 3

冷却三角	测点迎风风速
冷却三角	L-V1	L-V2	R-V1	R-V2
8号	2.31~4.86	1.57~3.45	1.65~3.77	1.37~5.36
9号	1.39~4.00	3.02~4.01	1.71~5.29	1.57~3.45

Fig. 8 Windward wind temperature distribution of the 8 cooling delta unit cooling column

Fig. 9 TWindward wind temperature distribution of the 9 cooling delta unit cooling column

Tab. 3 The range of wind temperature in sector 3

冷却三角	测点迎风风温
冷却三角	L-V1	L-V2	R-V1	R-V2
8号	10.51~13.07	11.36~13.74	10.20~12.83	10.45~13.20
9号	10.20~12.95	12.22~14.84	8.49~11.18	11.18~13.93

Tab. 4 Range of windward wall temperature in sector 3

位置	测点编号	8号冷却三角	9号冷却三角
左侧冷却柱迎风壁温/℃	L-T1	18.64~21.33	19.49~25.29
	L-T2	18.52~20.96	17.72~20.78
	L-T3	16.44~19.19	17.60~20.47
右侧冷却柱迎风壁温/℃	R-T1	19.43~22.30	19.80~22.55
	R-T2	18.82~21.45	18.52~20.96
	R-T3	17.85~20.59	16.44~19.19

Fig. 10 Windward wall temperature distribution of the 8 cooling delta unit cooling column

Fig. 11 Windward wall temperature distribution of the 9 cooling delta unit cooling column

Tab. 5 Outlet wall temperature of 1 and 2 cooling delta in sector 11 and the data of the environment

时间	1号出水柱壁温/℃	2号出水柱壁温/℃	环境风速/(m/s)	环境温度/℃	环境风向/(°)
13：00	25.23	22.51	2.72	-1.82	199.48
14：00	25.23	22.28	2.95	-1.18	210.15
15：00	24.85	22.86	2.93	-1.20	181.97
16：00	25.07	22.36	2.70	-1.37	168.46
17：00	25.53	22.39	3.14	-1.64	143.36
18：00	26.96	22.31	4.65	-1.88	137.50
19：00	28.27	22.59	5.68	-2.14	132.70
20：00	28.46	22.36	6.10	-2.16	156.71
21：00	28.76	22.15	6.61	-2.14	158.84

Tab. 6 Single side outlet wall temperature of 1 and 2 cooling delta in sector 11

时间	1号冷却三角			2号冷却三角
时间	左侧	右侧	差值	左侧	右侧	差值
13：00	25.34	25.12	0.22	22.64	22.38	0.26
14：00	25.29	25.17	0.12	22.33	22.23	0.11
15：00	24.70	25.00	0.30	21.66	22.07	0.42
16：00	25.03	25.11	0.08	22.32	22.41	0.09
17：00	25.43	25.62	0.19	22.31	22.47	0.16
18：00	26.86	27.06	0.21	22.26	22.36	0.11
19：00	28.38	28.15	0.23	22.65	22.53	0.12
20：00	28.84	28.09	0.75	22.68	22.04	0.65
21：00	28.90	28.63	0.27	22.39	21.91	0.48

Fig. 12 Change trend of 1 and 2 cooling delta units outlet water average temperature and ambient wind direction

Fig. 13 Change trend of 1 and 2 cooling delta units outlet water average temperature and ambient wind velocity

Fig. 14 Change trend of 1 and 2 cooling delta units outlet average water temperature and ambient temperature

Fig. 15 Change trend of the one-sided outlet column water temperature with time

Fig. 16 Change trend of the outlet water column and the temperature water difference of the inlet and outlet water on both sides of the 1 and 2 cooling delta units

References 24

1	国家发展改革委，国家能源局．全国煤电机组改造升级实施方案[EB/OL]．(2021-11-03)[2023-07-25]．. doi:10.3403/30197441
	562/files/ 044e56fa097944efa3f980ad0bd19588.pdf． National Development and Reform Commission，National Energy Administration．National coal-fired power unit transformation and upgrading implementation plan[EB/OL]．(2021-11-03)[2023-07-25]．. doi:10.3403/30197441
	044 e56fa097944efa3f980ad0bd19588.pdf． doi:10.3403/30197441
2	张全斌，周琼芳．基于“双碳”目标的中国火力发电技术发展路径研究[J]．发电技术，2023，44(2)：143-154． doi:10.12096/j.2096-4528.pgt.22092
	ZHANG Q B， ZHOU Q F ．Research on the development path of China’s thermal power generation technology based on the goal of “carbon peak and carbon neutralization”[J]．Power Generation Technology，2023，44(2)：143-154． doi:10.12096/j.2096-4528.pgt.22092
3	冯伟忠，李励．“双碳”目标下煤电机组低碳、零碳和负碳化转型发展路径研究与实践[J]．发电技术，2022，43(3)：452-461． doi:10.12096/j.2096-4528.pgt.22061
	FENG W Z， LI L ．Research and practice on development path of low-carbon， zero-carbon and negative carbon transformation of coal-fired power units under “double carbon” targets[J]．Power Generation Technology，2022，43(3)：452-461． doi:10.12096/j.2096-4528.pgt.22061
4	朱法华，许月阳，孙尊强，等．中国燃煤电厂超低排放和节能改造的实践与启示[J]．中国电力，2021，54(4)：1-8．
	ZHU F H， XU Y Y， SUN Z Q，et al ．Practice and enlightenment of ultra-low emission and energy-saving retrofit of coal-fired power plants in China[J]．Electric Power，2021，54(4)：1-8．
5	ZHAI H， RUBIN E， GROL E，et al ．Dry cooling retrofits at existing fossil fuel-fired power plants in a water-stressed region：tradeoffs in water savings，cost，and capacity shortfalls[J]．Applied Energy，2022，306：117997． doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2021.117997
6	KRÖGER D G ．Air-cooled heat exchangers and cooling towers： thermal-flow performance evaluation and design[M]．Tulsa，Oklahoma，USA：Pennwell Corporation，2004：361-400．
7	丁尔谋．发电厂空冷技术[M]．北京：水利电力出版社，1992：37-56．
	DING E M ．Air cooling technology for power plants[M]．Beijing：Water Conservancy and Electric Power Press，1992：37-56．
8	DU PREEZ A， KRÖGER D ．Effect of wind on performance of a dry-cooling tower[J]．Heat Recovery Systems & CHP，1993，13(2)：139-146． doi:10.1016/0890-4332(93)90033-r
9	韩华锋，陈庆杰，赵元宾，等．基于冷却幅高的间接空冷塔冷却特性分析与评价[J]．中国电机工程学报，2021，41(6)：2212-2221．
	HAN H F， CHEN Q J， ZHAO Y B， et al ．Analysis and evaluation of cooling characteristics of natural draft dry cooling tower based on the cooling approach[J]．Proceedings of the CSEE，2021，41(6)：2212-2221．
10	赵振国，石金玲，魏庆鼎，等．自然风对空冷塔的不利影响及其改善措施[J]．应用科学学报，1998(1)：112-120．
	ZHAO Z G， SHI J L， WEI D Q，et al ．The engineering improvement for weakening the bad effect of natural wind on the dry cooling towers[J]．Journal of Applied Sciences，1998(1)：112-120．
11	MA H， SI F， KONG Y，et al ．Wind-break walls with optimized setting angles for natural draft dry cooling tower with vertical radiators[J]．Applied Thermal Engineering，2017，112：326-339． doi:10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2016.10.071
12	MA H， SI F， ZHU K，et al ．The adoption of windbreak wall partially rotating to improve thermo-flow performance of natural draft dry cooling tower under crosswind[J]．International Journal of Thermal Sciences，2018，134：66-88． doi:10.1016/j.ijthermalsci.2018.08.005
13	CHEN L， YANG L， DU X，et al ．Performance improvement of natural draft dry cooling system by interior and exterior windbreaker configurations[J]．International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer，2016，96：42-63． doi:10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2016.01.021
14	WANG W， ZHANG H， LÜ J，et al ．Ventilation enhancement for a natural draft dry cooling tower in crosswind via windbox installation[J]．Applied Thermal Engineering，2018，137：93-100． doi:10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2018.03.059
15	赵元宾，孙奉仲．环境侧风下间接空冷塔水温分布特性的研究[J]．中国电机工程学报，2017，37(18)：5367-5376．
	ZHAO Y B， SUN F Z ．Study on water temperature distribution characteristics of dry cooling tower under crosswind impact[J]．Procedings of the CSEE，2017，37(18)：5367-5376．
16	CHEN L， YANG L， DU X，et al ．Performance improvement of natural draft dry cooling system by interior and exterior windbreaker configurations[J]．International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer，2016，96：42-63． doi:10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2016.01.021
17	ZHAO Y， LONG G， SUN F，et al ．Effect mechanism of air deflectors on the cooling performance of dry cooling tower with vertical delta radiators under crosswind[J]．Energy Conversion and Management，2015，93：321-331． doi:10.1016/j.enconman.2015.01.025
18	ZHAO Y， SUN F， LI Y，et al ．Numerical study on the cooling performance of natural draft dry cooling tower with vertical delta radiators under constant heat load[J]．Applied Energy，2015，149：225-237． doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2015.03.119
19	陈铁锋，陈庆杰，王立东，等．间接空冷冷却三角气侧流动传热特性实验研究[J]．中国电机工程学报，2020，40(S1)：188-194．
	CHEN T F， CHEN Q J， WANG L D，et al ．Experimental research on the air side flow and heat transfer characteristics of natural draft dry cooling tower cooling deltas[J]．Procedings of the CSEE，2020，40(S1)：188-194．
20	ZHANG K， LI M， LIU H，et al ．A general and rapid method to evaluate the effect of flow maldistribution on the performance of heat exchangers[J]．International Journal of Thermal Sciences，2021，170：107152． doi:10.1016/j.ijthermalsci.2021.107152
21	WANG Q， ZENG M， MA T，et al ．Recent development and application of several high-efficiency surface heat exchangers for energy conversion and utilization[J]．Applied Energy，2014，135：748-777． doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.05.004
22	KONG Y， WANG W， HUANG X，et al ．Wind leading to improve cooling performance of natural draft air-cooled condenser[J]．Applied Thermal Engineering，2018，136：63-83． doi:10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2018.02.100
23	MA H， SI F， WANG J ．Study on the effects of apex angle of the delta-type radiator on thermo-flow performance of natural draft dry cooling tower[J]．International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer，2020，148：119002． doi:10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2019.119002
24	赵元宾，孙奉仲，杨玉杰，等．一种间冷塔竖直三角型散热器的气侧均流系统：CN104613807B[P]．2016-06-22．
	ZHAO Y B， SUN F Z， YANG Y J， et al ．A kind of air-side current sharing system of vertical triangular radiator of intercooler cooling tower：CN104613807B[P]．2016-06-22．

[1]	Weizhong FENG, Li LI. Research and Practice on Development Path of Low-carbon, Zero-carbon and Negative Carbon Transformation of Coal-fired Power Units Under “Double Carbon” Targets [J]. Power Generation Technology, 2022, 43(3): 452-461.
[2]	Jiang FAN,Shuangping ZHANG,Yu MENG,Weixiong CHEN,Junjie YAN. Characteristics of NO_x Formation and Removal in the Transient Process of a 660 MW Coal-fired Power Unit [J]. Power Generation Technology, 2020, 41(5): 527-535.
[3]	Yuliang DONG,Jiahai YUAN,Lirong MA. Air Emissions Characteristics of Coal-Fired Power Unit for Flexibility Generation [J]. Power Generation Technology, 2018, 39(5): 425-432.
[4]	Haiyan MA,Lei ZHOU,Tingwen WANG,Jing ZHOU,Houzhang TAN,Limei JIN. Performance Diagnosis and Optimization of Flue Flow Field of 1060 MW Coal-Fired Unit [J]. Power Generation Technology, 2018, 39(3): 253-258.
[5]	Hui LONG,Jingjing HUANG. Development Direction Analysis of Coal-fired Power Units' Design Technology During the 13th Five-Year Plan [J]. Power Generation Technology, 2018, 39(1): 13-17.